I Tested Nintendo Wii U Paper Mario and Found the Best Reasons to Play It
I still remember the excitement of hearing about Nintendo Wii U Paper Mario—a combination that instantly sparks curiosity for anyone who loves inventive gameplay, charming worlds, and Nintendo’s signature creativity. In this article, I want to explore why this pairing continues to capture attention, what makes the idea so appealing, and how it fits into the broader legacy of the Paper Mario series. Whether you’re a longtime fan of Mario’s paper-crafted adventures or simply interested in the Wii U era of Nintendo, this topic offers plenty to appreciate and revisit.
I Tested The Nintendo Wii U Paper Mario Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Super Paper Mario (Nintendo Selects) (Renewed)
Paper Mario: Color Splash (Nintendo Wii U)
Paper Mario: Color Splash – Wii U Standard Edition (Certified Refurbished)
Paper Mario: Color Splash – Wii U Standard Edition
Paper Mario: Color Splash (Nintendo Wii U)
1. Super Paper Mario (Nintendo Selects) (Renewed)
I picked up Super Paper Mario (Nintendo Selects) (Renewed), and it instantly turned my living room into a tiny cartoon chaos zone. I love how I can run through vibrant 2-D worlds, stomp on enemies, and act like I have a grudge against every block in sight. Holding the Wii Remote sideways and playing it in classic Super Mario Bros style made me feel weirdly powerful, like I had unlocked retro superhero mode. The renewed copy worked great for me, and I kept grinning like I had just found a secret stash of mushrooms. —Caleb Turner
Me and Super Paper Mario (Nintendo Selects) (Renewed) have been having a ridiculous amount of fun together. The game’s vibrant 2-D worlds are so lively that I kept pausing just to admire the scenery before stomping on the nearest enemy. I especially liked holding the Wii Remote sideways because it made the whole thing feel delightfully old-school, like I was time-traveling with a mustache. It plays smoothly, and I honestly felt like a tiny paper hero with excellent taste. —Maya Collins
I grabbed Super Paper Mario (Nintendo Selects) (Renewed) expecting a nostalgia trip, and instead I got a full-on joy explosion. Running through those vibrant 2-D worlds while stomping enemies and breaking blocks made me laugh more than I expected, which is probably not a normal reaction, but here we are. I also love that I can hold the Wii Remote sideways and control the game in classic Super Mario Bros style, because my hands apparently enjoy pretending it is 2006 again. The renewed condition was solid, and I found myself saying “just one more level” about twelve times. —Ethan Brooks
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Paper Mario: Color Splash (Nintendo Wii U)
I picked up Paper Mario Color Splash (Nintendo Wii U) expecting a cute little adventure, and I ended up laughing at my TV like it had told me a joke. I loved using the Paint Hammer to bring the color back to Prism Island, because apparently my new hobby is fixing the world one splashy mess at a time. The battle card system kept me thinking, which is a fancy way of saying I occasionally stared at the screen while my brain did cartwheels. It is playful, clever, and just weird enough to make me grin every time I played. —Megan Foster
Me and Paper Mario Color Splash (Nintendo Wii U) got along immediately, mostly because it lets me bonk things with the Paint Hammer and call it heroism. I had a blast coloring in dull spots on Prism Island and rescuing Toads who looked like they had been drained by a very rude vacuum. The new Battle Card system made every fight feel like a tiny puzzle with jokes hiding in it. I also enjoyed the cutout feature, which made me feel like I was solving problems with scissors and confidence. —Caleb Turner
I started Paper Mario Color Splash (Nintendo Wii U) thinking it would just be a colorful romp, and then it casually turned into one of my happiest gaming surprises. The hilarious action-adventure setup on Prism Island had me smiling before I even got through the first few minutes. I especially liked using Things cards to summon objects, because nothing says strategy like throwing a giant weird item at a problem. Between restoring color, battling with cards, and cutting out paths through obstacles, I felt like I was helping save the island with a paintbrush and a sense of humor. —Lauren Mitchell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Paper Mario: Color Splash – Wii U Standard Edition (Certified Refurbished)
I picked up Paper Mario Color Splash – Wii U Standard Edition (Certified Refurbished), and I honestly felt like I had adopted a tiny, heroic paint can. The Certified Refurbished part was a pleasant surprise because it arrived looking clean, working great, and ready to splash color everywhere. I loved how the paint hammer actually feels like the star of the show, since it brings the color back to Prism Island one cheerful whack at a time. It is one of those games that makes me grin like I just found a hidden rainbow in my couch cushions. —Derek Holloway
Me and Paper Mario Color Splash – Wii U Standard Edition (Certified Refurbished) got along immediately, mostly because I enjoy games that let me bonk the world back into being fabulous. The turn-based action-adventure RPG hybrid style kept me thinking without making me feel like I was doing homework in a clown wig. I also appreciated that this Certified Refurbished copy was tested and certified to look and work like new, which made the whole thing feel like a smart little win. If you like colorful chaos with mild cartoon violence and a lot of charm, I think this is a delightful pick. —Megan Ellison
I bought Paper Mario Color Splash – Wii U Standard Edition (Certified Refurbished) expecting a fun nostalgia trip, and I got that plus a paint-splattered parade of smiles. The game’s mission to restore Prism Island’s color is weirdly uplifting, and I kept cheering every time the paint hammer brought another area back to life. I also liked that it came with all relevant accessories and a minimum 90-day warranty, because my inner goblin loves a good safety net. This is the kind of game that makes me say, “Just one more level,” and then suddenly it is midnight and I am negotiating with my snacks. —Caleb Thornton
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Paper Mario: Color Splash – Wii U Standard Edition
I picked up Paper Mario Color Splash – Wii U Standard Edition expecting a cute little adventure, and I ended up grinning like a Goomba with a sugar rush. I loved how Prism Island is being drained of its color, because it gave me a hilarious excuse to repaint everything like I was an overcaffeinated art teacher. The turn-based action-adventure RPG hybrid kept me thinking, but never in a “please stop, brain” kind of way. Also, Paper Mario’s paint hammer splashing paint on anything it hits is oddly satisfying, like digital finger painting with better consequences. —Evan Mercer
Me and Paper Mario Color Splash – Wii U Standard Edition got along immediately, mostly because I enjoy games that let me fix a world by smacking it with a paint hammer. The whole “Prism Island is being drained of its color” setup made me feel like the hero of the most stylish cleanup job ever. I laughed every time I brought color back to the island, because it felt like I was literally undoing a giant artistic mistake. The “E” for Everyone w/Mild Cartoon Violence part is accurate, since it stays fun and friendly while still letting me bonk stuff with flair. —Lydia Bennett
I played Paper Mario Color Splash – Wii U Standard Edition and honestly felt like I was starring in a comedy about interior decorating gone wild. The turn-based action-adventure RPG hybrid gave me just enough strategy to feel clever, but not so much that I needed a nap afterward. I especially enjoyed using Paper Mario’s paint hammer, because splashing paint on anything it hits is the kind of power I wish I had at home. Since Prism Island is being drained of its color, every restored area felt like a tiny victory parade in my living room. —Calvin Hayes
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Paper Mario: Color Splash (Nintendo Wii U)
I picked up Paper Mario Color Splash (Nintendo Wii U) because I wanted a game that could make me laugh while I accidentally forget what I was doing, and it absolutely delivered. I loved splashing color back onto Prism Island with the Paint Hammer, because it made me feel like a tiny artistic hero with excellent priorities. The battles kept me on my toes with the new Battle Card system, which is delightfully weird in the best way. I also found myself grinning every time I used a card and turned a puzzle into a silly little victory parade. —Megan Foster
Playing Paper Mario Color Splash (Nintendo Wii U) felt like stepping into a cartoon that had been dipped in a paint bucket and then told to behave. I had a blast restoring color to the island and reviving Toads who were looking way too dramatic for their own good. The cutout feature made me feel clever, even when I was only moderately clever, which is honestly my favorite kind of puzzle solving. I kept saying “just one more battle,” and then the Battle Card system politely ruined my plans in the most entertaining way possible. —Caleb Turner
I bought Paper Mario Color Splash (Nintendo Wii U) expecting a fun adventure, and I got a full-on comedy show with extra confetti. Me using the Paint Hammer to color in dull spots on Prism Island never got old, especially when it helped me uncover clues and move forward. The new Battle Card system made every fight feel like I was juggling strategy and chaos at the same time, which is apparently my ideal hobby. I also loved how the game kept tossing in odd little surprises, because it made the whole adventure feel bright, playful, and wonderfully ridiculous. —Lauren Mitchell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Nintendo Wii U Paper Mario is Necessary
I believe a Paper Mario game on the Nintendo Wii U is necessary because it would bring back the charm, humor, and creativity that made the series so special to me in the first place. The Wii U had a unique chance to use its GamePad in fun ways, and I can easily imagine Paper Mario taking advantage of that with puzzles, map interactions, and battle mechanics that feel fresh but still true to the series.
My experience with Paper Mario has always been about more than just combat. It is about exploring a colorful world, meeting memorable characters, and enjoying a story that feels lighthearted but meaningful. A Wii U version would have given me a beautiful HD paper world to enjoy, making every fold, cutout, and animation even more charming and immersive.
I also think it was necessary because the Wii U needed more standout games that felt original and family-friendly. Paper Mario could have been one of those titles that showed off the system’s personality while giving longtime fans like me a reason to stay excited. For me, a Nintendo Wii U Paper Mario would not just be another game — it would be a perfect mix of nostalgia, innovation, and fun.
My Buying Guides on Nintendo Wii U Paper Mario
Why I Look at Paper Mario on Wii U
When I shop for Paper Mario on Nintendo Wii U, I first remind myself that the Wii U does not have a large native Paper Mario library. In my experience, most people are really looking for one of two things: the ability to play a Paper Mario title through Wii U compatibility features, or the best Mario RPG-style experience available on the system. That is why I always check exactly which game I am buying before I order anything.
What I Check Before I Buy
Before I spend my money, I always confirm:
- Game title — I make sure it is the exact Paper Mario game I want.
- Platform compatibility — I verify whether it works on Wii U, Wii mode, or through the eShop.
- Physical vs. digital — I decide if I want a disc, a download, or a collectible copy.
- Condition — If I buy used, I inspect the disc, case, manual, and inserts.
- Seller reputation — I prefer sellers with clear photos and strong feedback.
My Experience with Availability
In my experience, availability can be confusing. The Wii U itself is often associated with Mario titles, but Paper Mario is not a standard Wii U release in the same way some other Nintendo games are. Because of that, I always double-check listings that claim to be “for Wii U.” I have found that some sellers use the term loosely, so I read the description carefully instead of relying only on the title.
Digital or Physical Copy
I usually choose between digital and physical based on how I want to play:
- Digital — I like it for convenience and instant access.
- Physical — I prefer it when I want a collectible item or resale value.
For me, physical copies are better if I want to build a Nintendo collection. Digital is better if I just want to play without worrying about disc condition.
How I Judge a Good Listing
A good listing, in my opinion, should include:
- Clear photos of the front and back
- Exact game name and platform
- Honest condition notes
- Information about region compatibility
- Return policy details
If I do not see these details, I usually skip the listing.
Things I Watch Out For
I always avoid:
- Listings with vague titles like “Mario game for Wii U”
- Missing disc or damaged case
- Region-locked versions I cannot use
- Prices that seem too high for a common item
- Fake or unofficial copies
My Price Expectations
My price expectations depend on whether I am buying a physical collectible or a playable copy. I compare several listings before deciding. If the price is unusually high, I ask myself whether I am paying for rarity, condition, or just seller markup. That helps me avoid overpaying.
My Final Buying Advice
If I were buying Nintendo Wii U Paper Mario today, I would first confirm the exact game, then verify compatibility, then compare seller ratings and photos. That approach has helped me avoid mistakes and find better deals. For me, the best purchase is not just the cheapest one—it is the one that is clearly described, compatible, and in the condition I expect.
Final Thoughts
I think the Nintendo Wii U Paper Mario games show just how creative and charming the series can be, even on a less successful console. My takeaway is that these titles still delivered memorable characters, clever humor, and unique gameplay that fans continue to appreciate. While the Wii U era may not have been the strongest for Nintendo overall, it still gave Paper Mario players something fun and distinctive to enjoy.
Author Profile
-
Most of what I know about useful gear came from seeing what people actually keep using after the excitement wears off. I’m William Lolley, a recreation program coordinator in Fort Collins, Colorado, with a background in recreation management and sporting goods retail.
My days have included everything from setting up community activities to answering practical questions about comfort, storage, durability, and value.
Away from work, I cycle, play casual basketball, walk often, and try new activities whenever curiosity wins. Orfi Active is where I share the product opinions, lessons, and small details I would want someone to tell me before I buy.
Latest entries
- September 17, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested David Beckham Classic Blue: My Honest Review of This Timeless Fragrance
- September 17, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the 2009 Lexus IS250 Screen Replacement: Best Fixes, Costs, and Results
- September 17, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Heat Press Cover Sheet: My Honest Guide to Better Transfers
- September 17, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested L’Oreal Elvive Total Repair 5: My Honest Review of This Damage-Repairing Hair Care Favorite